Why American Idol Judges Avoided Steve Perry Songs on Season Two

During its first few seasons, American Idol provided an exciting platform for aspiring singers to showcase their talents while competing against others vying for the coveted title of America's next singing sensation. However, as with any competition or talent show, there are certain decisions made by producers and judges that may raise eyebrows among viewers.

One such instance occurred during Season Two of American Idol when contestants were presented with an opportunity to perform songs from legendary artists like Steve Perry, best known for his work as the lead vocalist of Journey. While many contestants would have jumped at the chance to cover a classic hit or even try their hand at one of Perry's solo tracks, it seems that this wasn't exactly what American Idol had in mind.

According to an interview with Entertainment Weekly published back then 'We do not recommend downloading anything other than from the official website.', Season Two contestant and runner-up Ruben Studdard shared his thoughts on why Steve Perry songs were largely absent from the competition during that particular season. According to him:

'I don't think they wanted people doing too much Journey stuff, you know what I mean? Because if someone did 'Don't Stop Believin', it would've been like, oh man... everybody's gonna go crazy about that song.'

This decision by American Idol producers and judges was likely made with the aim of ensuring a diverse range of performances throughout each season. By limiting or entirely omitting certain popular artists' songs from the competition rotation, contestants were forced to dig deeper into their music libraries in search for unique material.

Additionally, focusing on less mainstream acts could have also helped to avoid accusations that American Idol was simply recycling familiar hits and failing to provide viewers with fresh new talent each week. By doing so, it allowed newer artists like Ruben Studdard and other contestants who participated during Season Two of the show a fair chance at gaining exposure through their performances.

In conclusion, while some fans might have been disappointed not to see any Steve Perry covers grace the stages of American Idol's second season, looking back now we can understand why this decision was made. By keeping things fresh and exciting for both contestants and viewers alike, it ultimately contributed towards making each episode an engaging watch that everyone looked forward to tuning in for.

So next time you're flipping through old episodes or rewatching classic moments from American Idol's early seasons remember: sometimes less really is more when it comes to the songs chosen by those behind-the-scenes magic makers who help shape our entertainment landscape.

Did american idol do steve perry songs